How To Save Rhino
The holocaust of the African rhinoceros is accelerating, with the very real possibility that both the continent’s species – white and black rhinos – could be extinct outside zoos in a matter of years. At the beginning of the 20th century, there were several hundred thousand rhinos in East and southern Africa. European settlers described the bush immediately outside Nairobi as stiff with black rhino.
Today, there are perhaps 5,000 black rhinos and 20,000 white rhinos left on the continent, but even these numbers must be considered optimistic; the killing has reached such a frenzied pitch that the only thing that’s certain is that the populations are in free-fall.
The root causes for the slaughter remain the same — demand for rhino horn in traditional Asian medicine,and to a lesser degree, the use of the horns for handles on heirloom-quality Yemeni daggers. But one big thing has changed: Asia has money now. Formerly impoverished factory workers and farmers are, by the metrics of the past, rich. Many can afford to buy rhino horn, even at the currently stratospheric price of$66,000 a kilo. Supposedly, interest in the horn is slackening in China and picking up in Vietnam; but by any measure, the demand continues to climb.
What to do? Right now, hand-wringing seems the fashion. Animal rights and conservation groups have sounded the tocsin as usual, pleading for still more money to “save the rhino.” But you can’t find enough donor money to counter the cartel-scale financing that’s driving the slaughter. Poachers suborn game scouts and rangers, who provide specific details on the location of the animals; kills are made from helicopters with muffled blades. In the face of such industrial poaching, a few more rehabilitation centers for orphaned rhino calves, a few more scouts patrolling the reserves, aren’t going to make a whit of difference. Nor will the tears of the myriad celebrities and animal lovers who dote on large, charismatic mammals, rhinos included.
Some people who actually work with rhinos on a daily basis, though, have a pretty good idea: sell horn from farmed rhinos through a legal and regulated market. Horns can be detached from tranquilized rhinos quickly, safely, and painlessly. This does two things: removes the poachers’ incentives for killing rhinos, and provides an extremely valuable product which can be sold to aid rhino conservation (Right now, of course, the sale of rhino horn is barred by the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species; a variance in the CITES proscription will be necessary to allow legal trade.)
Rhinos are easily raised and bred in captivity, and their populations can be expanded relatively rapidly for introduction into the wild. Today, such endeavors are fruitless — the rhinos are killed almost as fast as they’re released. The dynamic must change at a very basic level, and this will require some deep and painful soul-searching on the part of conservationists. John Hume, the owner of the Mauricedale Game Ranch in South Africa, is the largest private rhino breeder in the country, and few if any people have a better grasp on this issue. He and his staffers observe there is a compelling precedent for changing the rules for rhinos:vicuña.
These wild relatives of the llama were hunted almost to extinction for their ultra-fine wool, which was — and remains — much in demand for luxury garments. From an estimated pre-European contact population of two million animals, vicuña had fallen to about 6,000 when they were first accorded some protection in the mid-1960s. They were listed under CITES in 1975, and all trade in vicuña products halted. Poaching, however, remained rampant, and the future looked bleak — well, non-existent — for this wild South American camelid.
In 1979, however, a conservation agreement was signed by Peru, Bolivia, Chile, and Ecuador, and work began on several fronts — including the private sector. Most dramatically, Grupo Inca, a Peruvian textile manufacturer, began the “Shear a Vicuña, Save a Vicuña” campaign — the idea being, of course, that you can remove a vicuña’s wool without killing the animal. Several couture houses jumped on the bandwagon, including Loro Piana, which actively solicited local communities for sheared vicuña wool.
Today, more than 30 years later, vicuñas number close to 350,000. CITES has lifted its ban on vicuña products from Chile and Peru. Haut couturiers have plenty of vicuña wool for their creations. And local farmers and pastoralists, who once poached the animals relentlessly, now utilize them for a sustainable income. Animals are captured, sheared, and returned to the wild
It may seem vicuña and rhinos are apples and oranges, but their situations are analogous. Both species yield products much in demand. In both cases, these products can be obtained without killing the animals. And the people who share the land with both species are the key players in the animals’ survival. Rhinos are not being wiped out in Africa because African pastoralists and petty officials are inordinately cruel. Rhinos are being killed because rural Africans are poor. Participation in a single rhino hunt can mean the difference between starvation and a modest degree of prosperity. The needs of rural communities must be taken into account if the rhino is to survive. That doesn’t mean hand-outs — it means incentives that make living rhinos valuable to local farmers, herders, and bureaucrats.
Similarly, private rhino breeders have the expertise and means to expand rhino numbers. They will do just that if they have the appropriate stimulus, i.e., profit. Private enterprise doesn’t always create a virtuous circle, but in this case it can: the rhino, rural communities, conservation NGOs and rhino breeders would all benefit. When there is plenty of rhino horn on the market, prices will fall, the incentives to kill rhinos will diminish, and the number of rhinos in the wild will increase.
Resistance to this idea will be reflexive. And yes, there is something repugnant about commodifying the African rhino. But we can’t afford normative thinking — yearning for what “should” be because it’s “right.” Things are what they are – and for the rhino, the situation is at DefCon One. Everything that has been tried to this point has failed miserably. We need a new plan.
About endoftheiconsTripa peat swamps, once hosting the largest density of orangutan population in the world are now being exterminated by palm oil company working illegally. The last bits of the peat swamp forest are being smashed and sumatran orangutan are forced towards local extinction. are we witnessing the end of the icons? what are we doing about it?
- Indonesia Smoke Haze Shrouds Malaysian Cities wp.me/p2k0o5-qq 2 days ago
- Illegal wildlife trade flourishes in Sumatra wp.me/p2k0o5-qj 1 week ago
- RT @GreenSolarWind: Activist Post: Monsanto Concedes Defeat in the Face of Europe's Fierce Opposition to GMOs wp.me/p21Niz-ZU 1 week ago
- RT @ProbWithPalmOil: "the fastest, most comprehensive transformation of an entire landscape that has ever taken place anywhere” http://t.co… 1 week ago
- RT @RLSaussaye: Too many people undervalue what they are, and overvalue what they're not... 1 week ago
- Death by a thousand cuts: story of Avatar, Rahul, and Chocolate saveorangutans.org/in-the-shadows… 1 week ago
- Listed as allies by @RAN yay! 1 week ago
- Please help us bring @PAULJHILTON back! Donate on this link saveorangutans.org/urgent-call-fo… and help spread the word. Thank you! 1 week ago
- We were fortunate to have @PAULJHILTON with us, photographing and documenting the whole process with his amazing photography skill 1 week ago
- Once we found him, we pull all the efforts to confiscate him from the hands of the traders and take him to safety in @socp_tweets quarantine 1 week ago
- Chocolate was found in a house of a trader by our undercover team in June last year, when he was found, he was very skinny and malnourished. 1 week ago
- Dear friends, do you remember the story of chocolate? The baby Orangutan on our profile picture? 1 week ago
- RT @EIAinvestigator: @endoftheicons: Greed beats logic: why a legal #rhino horn trade won’t work ow.ly/lOCrp #SouthAfrica #Vietn… 1 week ago
- RT @GreenpeaceID: Satu pesan pelayaran kapal Greenpeace Rainbow Warrior, Selamatkan Hutan Indonesia untuk Masa Depan… instagram.com/p/aN6oITzQiF/ 1 week ago
- <3 “@dooledge: We keep Greenpeace independent -@greenpeaceid Fundraising team with supporters #indonesia Instagram.com/p/aN5YBgBZ3r/” 1 week ago
- RT @EIAinvestigator: Number of #elephant orphans in #Kenya rises ow.ly/lLxyd via @dswt #ivory 1 week ago
- RT @EnvironmeEnergy: Returning rare bumblebee to Britain is a dauntingly complex mission - The Guardian dlvr.it/3TT4g0 1 week ago
- RT @EIAinvestigator: RT @revkin: Jackie Chan hopes China and Vietnam (where rhino horn is a club drug) can build conservation ethic. http:/… 1 week ago
- RT @Gary_Chandler: @OuTrop @SumatraEEC @Unilever @Cargill What we need is biodiversity not monoculture that excludes wildlife. Plantations … 1 week ago
- Help us bring @PAULJHILTON to Aceh to document destruction at this critical time! Please chip in! Every bit counts! saveorangutans.org/urgent-call-fo… 1 week ago
- Indonesia Smoke Haze Shrouds Malaysian Cities
- Illegal wildlife trade flourishes in Sumatra
- More or less protection for forests in Indonesia?
- AP/ June 5, 2013, 7:51 AM Indonesia critically endangered Sumatran elephants poisoned, shot, WWF says
- Urgent Call for Help
- Indonesia on right path to saving forests: Greenpeace
- Mining in Indonesia taking a heavy social, environmental toll
- Battling Deforestation In Indonesia, One Firm At A Time
- Making the right choice on Indonesia’s forest moratorium
- Aceh Government and CSO Coalition Discussed New Spatial Plan
- World’s largest REDD project finally approved in Indonesia
- Government to revoke concessions in customary forests
- Government to revoke concessions in customary forests
- Indonesia extends logging moratorium, but questions remain
- Conservationists warn against keeping wild animals as pets
- Guardian Global Development ‘The Sumatran rainforest will mostly disappear within 20 years’
- Why Indonesia’s deforestation ban isn’t enough to protect its forests
- Indonesia and environmental sustainability: Walking the talk?
- Can REDD save the forests of Aceh?
- [Press Release] Aceh Forests facing numerous threats